Organic Farmers Plan Hydroponics Protest at Federal Policy Meeting


By Sustainable Food News

A large group of "hard-core, old-time, organic farmers" are planning a rally at next month's National Organic Standards Board (NOSB) meeting in Jacksonville, Fla., to protest the U.S. Department of Agriculture for allowing hydroponically grown produce to be certified as organic.

Hydroponics is a hot-button issue that has split the organic foods industry, with one side advocating for soil-based organic production only and the other citing ambiguity in federal regulations that should allow certification of soil-less growing operations.

The NOSB, a 15-member panel of experts recommending organic policy to the USDA's National Organic Program (NOP), uses the term bioponics to describe food production systems that grow crops without soil using solid and liquid fertilizers that are allowed in organic farming.

The four bioponic production systems include:

  • hydroponics - a method of growing plants with roots in a mineral nutrient solutions in water without soil
  • aeroponics - a variation of hydroponics in which plant roots are suspended in air and misted with nutrient solution
  • aquaponics - a recirculating hydroponic plant production system in which plants are grown in nutrients originating from aquatic animal waste water, which may include the use of bacteria to improve availability of these nutrients to the plants. The plants improve the water quality by using the nutrients, and the water is then recirculated back to the aquatic animals
  • containers - systems that grow crops in containers, and supply nutrients through the combination of solid fertilizers mixed into the growing media as well as liquid fertilizers delivered through irrigation systems

For the upcoming Jacksonville meeting, the NOSB's Crops subcommittee has put together a proposal that delineates the four bioponic production systems:

  • Aeroponics - proposal opposes allowing aeroponic production systems to be certified organic because they do not meet the requirements of OFPA or the Organic Rule.
  • Aquaponics - proposal opposes allowing aquaponic production systems to be certified organic at this time. If aquaculture standards are issued in the future, and concerns about food safety are resolved, aquaponics could be reconsidered.
  • Container production - proposal would allow container production to be certified organic as long as a limit of 20 percent of the plants’ nitrogen requirement can be supplied by liquid feeding, and a limit of 50 percent of the plants’ nitrogen requirement can be added to the container after the crop has been planted. For perennials, the nitrogen feeding limit is calculated on an annual basis. Transplants, ornamentals, herbs, sprouts, fodder, and aquatic plants are exempted from these requirements.
  • Hydroponics - "Motion that any container production system that does not meet the standard of a limit of 20% of the plants’ nitrogen requirement being supplied by liquid feeding, and a limit of 50% of the plants’ nitrogen requirement being added to the container after the crop has been planted is defined as hydroponic and should not be allowed to be certified organic."

So, while a "yes" vote for the proposal may put the hydroponics issue to rest, organic farmers will still stage a protest.

"I believe it is our duty as organic farmers to defend the integrity of what has been handed down to us by our forebears," said organic farming pioneer Eliot Coleman in a letter to organic farmers announcing the rally. "The protection of that heritage is a responsibility that I don’t take lightly. The importance of optimal soil fertility as the bedrock of organic farming has to be transmitted accurately to future generations, so they can continue this effort. Since the USDA refuses to stop this hydroponic/organic fraud, I am asking all serious organic farmers to take effective action themselves."

The rally and protest is scheduled to kick off Oct. 31 just after lunchtime at the Omni Jacksonville Hotel, where a march will begin to The Landing, an entertainment venue on the St. John's River.

Speakers at the rally will include: Eliot Coleman, Fred Kirschenmann, Enid Wonnacott, Jim Riddle, Will Allen, Dave Chapman, Anaise Beddard, Tom Beddard, Linley Dixon, and Lisa Stokke.

For more information, click here.

Ocean Mist
Top Brass
Organic Grower Summit 2018
Organics Unlimited
MOM’s Organic Market: A Retailer with A Mission

MOM’s Organic Market: A Retailer with A Mission


For MOM’s Organic Market, the Mid-Atlantic region's premier chain of family owned and operated organic grocery stores with 18 locations, selling organic produce is not just an option, it’s a mission.

Read More
Proposal to Prohibit Bioponics: Set for Vote at NOSB Fall Meeting

Proposal to Prohibit Bioponics: Set for Vote at NOSB Fall Meeting


After 20 years of discussion, it is possible that the National Organic Standards Board will vote to prohibit aeroponics, hydronpoincs and aquaponics from official U.S.D.A. organic certification at its fall meetings in Jacksonville, FL, in early November.

Read More
Organic Pear Production on the Rise

Organic Pear Production on the Rise


Though not experiencing the rapid growth the Washington organic apple industry has seen, production of organic pears in the Northwest is experiencing steady expansion entering the fall.

Read More
Weekly Top 5: Organic News You Need to Know 

Weekly Top 5: Organic News You Need to Know 


  1. Wegmans Looks to Get Ahead of Organic Supply with Farming Innovations
  2. Organic Research Funding Bill Builds Bipartisan Support 
  3. Certified Organic Pot? Find Out Why Not! CCOF Webinar October 3, 2017
  4. Door to Door Organics Launches New Meal Planning Solution
  5. Are Packaging Claims Deterrents to Healthful Eating?
Read More
Top Brass
Organic Grower Summit 2018